I get some version of this question every week, usually from a founder with a great product and a Shopify store that isn't moving: "Should we be DTC?" Congrats on the product, truly. Now let's back up one step, because my answer starts with another question. What do you think DTC actually is?
Most people say it's selling online. That's the surface. I've been doing this for 15+ years, and the way I explain it to founders over coffee is a little different, so let me walk you through how I'd play it if I were starting today.
What does DTC mean?
DTC, or direct-to-consumer, means you sell to your customer without a retailer or wholesaler in the middle. You own the storefront, the price, the data and the relationship. Your site, your email and text list, your subscription, your community. When someone buys from you directly, you know who they are, and you get to earn the second order yourself.
That last part is the whole game. The first sale is nice. The relationship is the asset.
How DTC changed retail
For most of the last century, a consumer brand needed a buyer to say yes before a customer could even find it. Distribution was the moat. Digitally native brands flipped the order. They built an audience first, proved people wanted the thing, and then walked into retail with demand already in hand.
That shift is why a founder with a laptop can compete with a brand that has a hundred-year head start. It's also why the shelf now wants proof before it gives you space. I wrote about that sequence in Build the Demand First: getting into a big retailer is the start of the bill, so you want velocity in your pocket before you sign the PO.
Products are commoditized. Brands are why people buy.
I'll be honest, this part stings for a lot of founders. Almost any product can be made, copied and shipped fast. Your formula, your fabric, your flavor: somebody can get close within a few months. What they can't copy is the reason people pick you.
The way I say it to founders: brands are why they buy in the first place, and products are why they come back. A great product is the ticket to play. The brand is why they choose you when something cheaper shows up next to you.
The brands that try to be for everyone end up in what I call Blandville. Nobody remembers them, so every customer costs more than it should. So the first question I ask is simple: who does your brand piss off? If the answer is nobody, that's where we start.
How DTC marketing actually works
DTC marketing is the system for finding a new customer, getting them to buy, and bringing them back. I boil it down to three questions. How do I drive one net new customer in? How do I grow the basket? How do I get them to come back more often?
Think of a bucket. Paid media, creators, PR and partnerships pour new customers in. A weak product experience, a confusing site and a forgettable brand punch holes in the bottom. Most founders obsess over the hose. The money is in the holes.
I don't look at any of this through a funnel lens. I look at it as a flywheel, where every happy customer makes the next one cheaper to get.
On numbers, I keep it simple. Know what it costs you to get one new customer, which is your CAC. Know what that customer is actually worth after product, shipping and fees, which is your LTV, and only trust it once you've seen real people come back. And watch MER, your total revenue over your total marketing spend, because it's the one number that can't grade its own homework.
Founders love metrics that look good in a deck. ROAS tells you which channel wants the credit. MER tells you if the business works. I go deeper on that in MER vs ROAS. Pair it with new-customer CAC so your loyal customers don't hide a slide in acquisition. And remember the real test: you have a real business when you shut off all ads, income keeps coming in, and it keeps growing.
The game you're really playing: habits
The best DTC brands I've worked on lived inside something people already did every day. At GardenCup I built the brand as fractional CMO and brand partner, $0 to $29M in 18 months, and I'm still in their corner as an advisor. It's salads. Perishable, brutal to ship, shelf life measured in days. What made it work was the habit. Lunch happens every day.
That's the lens I'd use on any DTC idea. A habit product doesn't have to win the customer once. It wins them on a schedule, which means you can afford to pay more to acquire them and survive an ugly month of CAC.
Is DTC dead?
No. Cheap attention is gone, and that's a different thing. I wrote more about it in DTC Isn't Dead. Today DTC usually means omnichannel: your .com is home base, and Amazon, TikTok Shop and retail are places where the demand you built shows up. Owning the customer relationship still matters in every one of them.
Should your brand be DTC?
Probably yes, as home base, if people buy your product more than once and your margins can fund acquisition while you wait for that second order. It also helps a lot if you've got a story worth telling yourself, instead of hoping a retailer tells it for you.
If you sell a one-time, low-margin item, DTC alone is a tough road. Use it as your lab: prove demand, learn who your customer is, then take that proof to the channels where volume lives.
Quick answers
What is the difference between DTC and ecommerce?
Ecommerce is any sale that happens online, including a retailer selling your product on its site. DTC means the brand sells directly to the customer and owns the relationship and the data.
What is DTC marketing?
It's how a brand acquires, converts and retains customers directly, through owned channels like its site, email and text, plus paid media, creators and partnerships, measured on CAC, LTV and MER.
Can a DTC brand also sell in retail?
Yes, and most good ones eventually do. The play is to build demand direct first, so retail adds velocity to a brand people already want.
What should a new DTC brand focus on first?
Who it's for, what it promises, and whether people come back. Get those right before you scale spend.
Crawl, walk, run
I'm a crawl, walk, run guy. Own the relationship, know your numbers, give people a reason to pick you, and earn that second order before you pour fuel on it. I've watched plenty of founders do it the other way around, and it's a really expensive way to learn. I'm the biggest cheerleader in the world for people building things, so if you're in the thick of it, go hard in the paint.
If you want the whole framework in one place, grab the free Brand-Led Founder Playbook.
