Every few weeks a founder calls me with the same news, and I can hear the smile through the phone. A buyer said yes. The PO is coming. What do they do next?
I always say congrats first, because they earned it. Getting a buyer to say yes is hard, and plenty of great founders never get the meeting. Then I ask the question that kills the mood a little: on a random Tuesday, what's going to make a stranger pick you off that shelf?
That question is really what this whole piece is about. The pattern I keep seeing, over and over, is founders measuring what looks good instead of what pays. Doors look good. Velocity pays. And velocity comes from demand you built before you ever got to the shelf.
The big PO is the start of the bill
Getting into a big retailer isn't the win. It's the start of the bill.
Some of that bill is famous. Slotting fees are payments for shelf space, and when the FTC studied them in grocery back in 2003, the suppliers it surveyed said a nationwide launch of a new product could take \$1.5 to \$2 million in slotting alone. That's an old number from one channel, and every retailer works a little differently. Target, for example, doesn't run the kind of formal upfront slotting program some grocers use. The bill just shows up in other forms: promo and retail media you're expected to fund, freight to distribution centers, markdowns, and compliance chargebacks taken right off your invoice when a shipment is late or a label won't scan. Across CPG, PwC's Strategy& has put trade spending at roughly 20% of gross sales, second only to cost of goods.
You should still go. Just show up ready, because after the bill comes the grade. Retailers watch units per store per week, compare you to the rest of the category, and make room for somebody new at the next reset if you're slow. Getting the PO is like getting drafted. Great night. Now you have to make the roster.
Demand starts with picking a fight
So where does demand come from? Earlier than most people think. It starts with the question I ask in the first five minutes of almost every founder conversation: who are you pissing off?
I mean naming the incumbent whose customers you're taking, and being specific about it. When Dollar Shave Club and Harry's came up, they pointed straight at Gillette and the price of a cartridge, and guys who were already annoyed came running. Euromonitor had Gillette's US share of men's razors falling from more than 70% in 2010 to 54% in 2016.
A clear enemy is a CAC strategy. If your customer already buys the category and already has a gripe, your marketing can skip the lesson and just say switch. Brands that try to be for everyone land in what I call Blandville, where nobody remembers you and every customer costs more than they should.
We're living this with GLiTCH right now. Our foil is the regular candy aisle, the bag of gummy worms you were already going to grab at checkout, and every piece of creative we make starts there.
Forget the media budget. Set a CAC ceiling.
Once you know who you're coming for, the only question left is what you're willing to pay to get them. I don't believe in media budgets. A monthly number is a guess about the calendar, and it fails both ways: when a channel is working, you hit the number and shut off the winner, and when a channel is broken, you keep spending because the money was sitting there.
I run on unit economics and one threshold: the CAC ceiling, the most you're willing to pay to acquire one new customer. To find yours, start with what a new customer is worth over their first year in contribution margin, meaning after product, shipping and fees, and decide how fast you need that cash back. If you know your ceiling and you're buying customers under it, you have an "endless budget." Every customer you buy under the line earns its keep, so you keep buying. The only wall is cash flow and payback, meaning how much you can float before those customers pay you back.
To stay honest, watch two numbers every week. MER is total revenue divided by total marketing spend. aMER, or acquisition MER, is new-customer revenue divided by marketing spend. MER tells you whether the whole business works, and aMER tells you whether you're actually buying new customers or just getting credit for the people who already love you and buy again. When MER looks great and aMER slides, your returning customers are carrying you and new-customer CAC is creeping toward the ceiling.
Expect launch to be ugly. CAC is usually at its highest on day one, because nobody knows you yet and the ad platforms are still learning. Meta's own help center says ad sets in the learning phase are less stable and usually have a higher cost per result. Your job is to bring that number down with better creative and a better page. It climbs again as you scale into colder audiences, which is exactly why the ceiling decides when you pull back. Raise it when your customers prove they're worth more.
Think of it like a pitch count. You pull the pitcher when the numbers say he's done, whatever the inning says.
Fix the experience before you buy more traffic
I see this one constantly. The founder has the right product and the wrong experience. The product is simple, the site is complicated, and the sale dies on the page.
That's a money problem dressed up as a design problem. A lot of the people who bounce are people you already paid to bring in, so a confusing page quietly raises your CAC. Baymard Institute found that 17% of US online shoppers have abandoned an order because checkout was too long or complicated.
The test is simple. Hand your phone to someone who has never heard of you and don't explain anything. Do they get what it is, can they picture life after they buy it, and can they check out without asking you a single question? If not, sell the outcome first and let the product be the proof.
Fair warning, a great experience can't save a product people don't come back for. But if the product is right, the experience is usually the cheapest fix in the whole business, and it makes every dollar under your CAC ceiling work harder.
What retail-ready actually looks like
When you've done this work, the retail conversation changes. You walk in with a brand that already has a pull of its own, and the shelf becomes a place where that pull turns into velocity. Harry's built its customer base online starting in 2013 and went into Target stores in 2016, as its first mass retail partner. By the time it got there, it had shoppers who already knew the name.
Retail-ready, in my book, means you can answer a few things honestly. You know your repeat rate on .com, Amazon or TikTok Shop. You know your new-customer CAC and your ceiling. You can fund promo and a slow first quarter without sweating payroll. And you know exactly who you're stealing from, so a buyer can see in one slide why a shopper picks you over what's already there.
If you can't answer those yet, that's okay. It just tells you where to spend the next 90 days.
Build the demand first
I'm a crawl, walk, run guy. Prove it direct, get the page and the ceiling dialed in, and know who you're coming for. Then walk into the buyer meeting with receipts and let retail pour fuel on a fire you already lit.
If you're sitting on a PO right now, congrats. Truly. I'm the biggest cheerleader in the world for people building things. Now go make sure you're ready for the bill, and go hard in the paint to earn the reorder.
If you want the whole framework in one place, grab the free Brand-Led Founder Playbook.
