MER vs ROAS: which one should you trust?
MER. Marketing efficiency ratio is total revenue divided by total marketing spend, and it tells you whether the business works. ROAS tells you which platform wants the credit. When a creator video sparks the interest, Amazon closes the sale and a retargeting ad grabs the credit, MER is the only number in the room telling the truth.
I'll say it the way I say it on calls: ROAS is a bogus metric. That usually gets a laugh and then a little pushback, which I love, because founders have been taught to stare at it for years. So let me unpack it.
Founders love metrics that look good in a deck. Every ad platform grades its own homework. Meta counts the sale, Google counts the same sale, your email tool counts it too. Add up the dashboards and you'll find more revenue than ever hit your bank account. I've sat in more than a few meetings where everybody's channel was crushing it and the business was quietly losing money.
It gets worse once your brand actually starts working. Somebody sees a video, doesn't click, searches you three days later and buys on Amazon because Prime is sitting right there. The video did the work and gets zero credit. So if you run the company on ROAS, you end up cutting the things that create demand and pouring money into the things that just collect it. That's a slow, very expensive way to shrink.
How I'd actually run it
Keep it simple on purpose. Total revenue over total marketing spend, looked at weekly, judged over a month. One weekend tells you nothing. Four weeks tells you a lot.
Set your target from your margin, working back from your CAC ceiling, instead of borrowing a number from a podcast. And pair MER with new-customer CAC. This is the honest caveat: returning customers can make MER look amazing while you're quietly getting worse at finding new ones. The leaky bucket only fills if new people keep coming in.
My favorite test is the boring one. Shut a channel off for a few weeks and watch total revenue. If nothing moves, that channel was taking credit, not creating sales. And here's the bigger version of that test I give founders: you have a real business when you shut off all ads and income keeps coming in and growing.
Attribution has its place. It's for refining a business once you're at scale. Early on, trying to perfectly attribute every dollar is playing the wrong sport.
Quick answers
What's a good MER? Whatever your margin and repeat behavior say it needs to be. Work it backward from your own numbers.
Is MER only for big brands? It's actually easier for small brands, because you have fewer channels to add up. Start tracking it this week and future you will be grateful.
Should I still look at ROAS at all? Inside a single platform, sure. It's fine for picking the better ad. Just don't let it decide how much the whole business should spend.
If you want the full picture on owning the customer relationship, read What Is DTC. The free Brand-Led Founder Playbook lays out the sequence I use so growth never outruns the brand.
If you'd rather have a senior operator in the seat with you while you fix it, here's how I work as a fractional CMO.
